Young Stars Tournament All-Stars

Kevin McCartney
September 11 2013 12:35PM

 

 

One of the most interesting parts of the annual Young Stars tournament is seeing the talents of these young prospects relative to each other. With different systems in place, different ways of organizing lines, and even different levels of intensity about the tournament between franchises, wins and goals mean less than the process in evaluating player success. As one of the Nations Network scouts at the tournament, I thought I'd give my standouts, but in the hockey honoured tradition of naming All-Star teams. 

It's a small sample size, so these aren't necessarily the best prospects, but instead the prospects who had the best showing in the tournament. Still, I bet we see the majority of these names in NHL sweaters within a few years. 

1st All Star Team

Sean Monahan

Thinks hockey on a very high level. Only credited with two points, but was a dominating offensive force in game one against the Oilers and showed exceptional hockey awareness in adjusting to new defensive schemes in subsequent games. Uses team mates well and creates offence in new ways seemingly every shift. Did all the little things well and managed the game with his position as the best centres do.

Nic Petan

His first game against San Jose was the best single-game performance of the tournament among skaters, but he was a force throughout. Controlled play in both ends, with and without the puck. Outrageously quick hands, elite anticipation for this level, and a scorer's instinct. Backs off defenders with his skating and puck control. Distributes expertly from the middle lane to break traps. His two-way play was impeccable and his puck-support exceptional. A coach's dream at an extremely young age.

Hunter Shinkaruk

Led Canucks' forwards in scoring and looked dangerous with the puck the moment in touched his stick. Too fast for defencemen to handle in transition. Deceptive change of pace step low in the offensive end lets him avoid contact. Creates chaos for defenders. Shockingly physical with a nasty edge to his game and a mouth that just never stops. Got under the skin of every defender he faced and exploited their lapses in focus like a grade-A pest.

Brandon Davidson

Though his boxcars are not All-Star worthy, Davidson was a stand-out defender for the under-skilled Oilers. Strong puck movement, great sense for how to develop offence, and impressive blue line work were his most visible contributions. In fact, an excellent defender at both ends, with a mature awareness of passing lanes and stick placement, control of the play with angles, and tight gaps. Excellent skater, though a notch below the elite skaters in the tournament.

Brenden Kichton

Two goals in his first game, added two more assists and was +4 in the tournament while powering the Jets high-octane offence. Good-for-the-NHL level blue line control, excellent speed and control in his skating, and the puck skills to put drool on your chin. Lacks power in transition skating so can't battle while pivoting and uses looser gaps than ideal. Wasn't afraid to take contact to make plays, though, and trusted his reads to play a hesitation-free game.

Joni Ortio

A show-stopping performance against the Canucks with 39 saves on 40 shots. A large step ahead of the other goalies at the tournament. His athletics were impressive with two stolen goals on Kipper-esque drives and he tracked the play well, but it was his rebound control that set him apart. Didn't put a puck into danger during the game and even intentionally cleared the puck once by directing a hard shot around the glass.

2nd All Star Team

Markus Granlund

Powerful off the half-boards, strong in the cycle, and hard to beat on the end boards. Led the Flames in scoring and shots on. A dangerous powerplay player for the fact that he can create offence from anywhere in the zone and rotates well. Plays the simplified game of a pro player with the killer instinct to score with every play. Lacks the quickness of an NHL forward, but played the part well otherwise.

Bo Horvat

Sometimes hard to tell where his impact began and Shinkaruk's ended, but his chemistry with the quick winger came from excellent anticipation for both offence and defence. Cycled well. Quick release on his shot. Very high hockey IQ. He and Shinkaruk added complexity to their reps in practice and looked a cut above.

Adam Lowry

One of the few truly powerful skaters at the tournament with a compact, efficient stride, Lowry drove his giant 6'5" frame up and down the ice to great effect and with remarkable mobility. Full 200ft game, controlling the centre of the ice with his size and positioning. Pro-level strength already. Good anticipation and created offence from his two-way play, giving up little and driving the play the right way. A corsi-monster at this level.

John Ramage

Very effective transition game with smooth escapes, hard outlet passes, and puck support up ice. Uses good edge control and quick transition skating to keep play in front of him and maintain tight gaps. Made the position look easy in his second game against Vancouver and ended the tournament with 3 points in 3 games.

Josh Morrissey

Looked way too calm to be 18, and 'smooth' skater doesn't begin to describe his elite level technical control. Deliberate with the puck and often a step ahead of the play. Covered for Trouba often, who was pressing a little too hard in this tournament, and threw a gross hit on Jackson Houck that got him tossed from a game. Otherwise might have had more than just three points.

Joacim Eriksson

A couple weak goals against the Flames in which he lost the angle, but otherwise played a collected and controlled game. Efficient movements made for few gaps despite not having the size of some of the netminders in the tournament. Seven goals against on 102 shots in a tournament not known for its defence.

 

Honourable Mentions

  • Marco Roy: If he had played game one like he did game 3, he would have made the first team. Dynamic and creative attacker, strong-two way play. A cerebral player with puck skills to match.
  • Michael Ferland: Showed excellent vertical offence and protected the puck well. Good speed and physical. Cycled well. Hard shot, though not able to disguise his release. Lacked variety in his offence I think due to slow feet in changing direction (the power forward train tracks), but managed a point in every game and created room for his linemates.
  • Niklas Jensen: Looks like a professional-level player with elite speed, a love for contact, and a quick release shot. Owns his wing in transition by backing off defenders, which also opens up lanes across the top. Somehow the puck just wouldn't go in for him, but looked like one of the dozen or so players who could make the jump this year.
  • Cole Cassels: Started the tournament looking like an energy forward on a checking line and slowly moved up the roster with three points in four games. Always seemed to be attacking the net. Wanted to keep the tempo high, putting opponents off balance, but showing little ability to adjust his game to circumstance.
  • Matthew Nieto: I didn't cover the Sharks, but Nieto stood out in every game. Great range, mature two-way game. Generated a lot of offence and made veteran plays all over the ice.
  • Keegan Kanzig: Really surprised at this tournament with high-end hockey sense and good range. His size is unreal but his skating forces him to keep large gaps so he rarely gets his hands on people. Threw the kind of hits that make you glad you're not a hockey player. Strong transition passing and supported the play up-ice.
  • Kyle Bigos: Another stand-out for the Sharks and a former Oiler prospect. Really big and physical in his defending. But the impressive part was his transition game. Kept tight gaps, used his stick well, and made choices for opposing forwards with his focus and positioning. Transitioned up quickly and precisely. Above average mobility, but not near NHL level. Was exposed by Shinkaruk in particular.
  • Juho Olkinuora: Even forgetting his great hit along the sideboards against Nieto, Olkinuora showed exceptional confidence. Tracked the play well, controlled rebounds. Very good with the puck. Didn't communicate with this defence well.

Young Stars Coverage

You can check out our detailed game reports and a general overview at the links below.

38cf2c318f1f284f974b60f35021d346
Kevin is the Managing Editor of Jets Nation. His work has been featured on Bleacher Report, The Sporting News, and around the Nations Network. An enthusiastic over-analyst, his background and interests are diverse, but you might notice he's obsessed with hockey. Track him down on twitter @kevinmccart or @nhljetsnation
Avatar
#1 Kent Wilson
September 11 2013, 12:48PM
Trash it!
16
trashes
Props
38
props

Great way to cap an outstanding series. Thanks Kevin.

Avatar
#2 McRib
September 11 2013, 01:12PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
13
props

Nice piece only surprise is no mention of Emile Poirier. Especially when Hunter Shinkaruk was so highly regarded, head-to-head Poirier looked far more superior to me. I'm baised of course, but Hunter Shinkaruk just doesn't seem to have improved his game much over the past year and a half (possibly even regressed). If he is going to make the NHL its with this current skill set is it enough? Where Poirier is only touching the surface after he improved his skating by leaps and bounds late in the second half last year.

Nic Petan is a stud, still kind of wish we took him with that Klimchuk pick (not that I don't like him) or if the Flames would stop trading our second rounder’s could have got him as well!!!! He is a Top. 10 talent except for size. I actually think having undersized forwards like Johnny Gaudreau, Markus Granlund in the ranks was a deterrent for drafting Petan. Why don't teams just draft best available and then trade if necessary.

Still wonder why NYI didn't sign Brenden Kichton?!?! Everything else was bang on, Winnipeg is quitely putting together a solid crop of prospects.

Avatar
#4 Kent Wilson
September 11 2013, 02:06PM
Trash it!
60
trashes
Props
9
props

I like that I got trashed for thanking Kevin for his contributions.

Avatar
#5 TRAVb
September 11 2013, 02:39PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
0
props

Any info on flames camp tomorrow? Ice times roster etc. can't see anything on their website...

Avatar
#6 Kent Wilson
September 11 2013, 02:50PM
Trash it!
10
trashes
Props
1
props

@TRAVb

Not yet. Still waiting.

Avatar
#7 Bean-counting cowboy
September 11 2013, 03:24PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
12
props

I've been impressed with your analysis of this tourney Kevin. To be able to pick out that much detail is difficult, as so much is happening so fast on the ice. It is also clear you have a fluent understanding of the game. Nice work.

Avatar
#8 Kent Wilson
September 11 2013, 03:28PM
Trash it!
45
trashes
Props
9
props

13 trashes on one comment now? YOU CAN ALL GO TO HELL.

Avatar
#9 BurningSensation
September 11 2013, 03:52PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
14
props

So....the Oilers send Klefbom. Gernat and Marincin at defense, but it's Keegan 'Killdozer' Kanzig who gets the honorable mention,

Nice. :-)

Avatar
#10 Kent Wilson
September 11 2013, 03:54PM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Props
13
props

@BurningSensation

There's a good reason to hope Kanzig makes the NHL - one of the best hockey names ever.

Avatar
#11 beloch
September 11 2013, 03:59PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
11
props

Shinkaruk might be a pest in the best case scenario, but he might just be a discipline problem. The way he threw his stick down on the ice and threw a tantrum while play was still live after Ortio robbed him... Not acceptable. He's going to need to be quite exceptional for any team to put up with that crap.

Avatar
#12 BurningSensation
September 11 2013, 04:29PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
7
props
Kent Wilson wrote:

There's a good reason to hope Kanzig makes the NHL - one of the best hockey names ever.

I'm more jacked by the sheer volume of prospects we have bubbling under. Monahan gets 1st team, Granlund and Ramage 2nd, Ortio, Ferland, and Kanzig HMs.

And not an Oiler in sight (ok, ok, Marco Roy was an HM)

As a rebuilding team having that many guys flashing strong potential is a serious cause for optimism!

Monahan being our top pick in a deep draft is no surprise, and with Ramage being older he really isn't either. But Granlund, Ortio, Ferland and Kanzig were all something of a surprise for me at the tournament.

To steal from Andrew Sullivan, 'know hope'

Avatar
#13 beloch
September 11 2013, 04:45PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
9
props

@BurningSensation

To be fair to the Oilers, Yakupov (19), the Nuge (20) and Hall (21) are all young enough to have been in this tournament and probably would have topped everyone's lists. The flipside is that they really don't have many other kids left in their system to get excited about. Also, while they will be hard pressed to make the playoffs this year and may peak as a bubble team, the Oilers probably won't pick in the top 5 again for quite a while.

I'm a little worried about Vancouver personally. They have decidedly too many good prospects for a team that was recently a cup contender. If they choose to squander that in a bid to contend, I hope Burke and Feaster (Beaster?) are first in line to fleece them (so long as they don't try to pick up Shinkaruk)!

What I find encouraging for the Flames is that they made such a good showing with so many top prospects out of the picture! Gillies, Gaudreau, Klimchuk , and Jankowski (okay, I'm being optimistic about Janko.) were all unable to attend the tournament.

Avatar
#14 They're $hittie
September 11 2013, 05:09PM
Trash it!
22
trashes
Props
1
props

hahahaa, your messiah Sven isnt an allstar

Avatar
#15 BurningSensation
September 11 2013, 05:21PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
5
props

@beloch

Yeah, being fair to the Oilers isn't really my thing.

That said, 1st overall players are rarely considered 'prospects'.

Avatar
#16 Primo
September 11 2013, 06:52PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
6
props

Kevin, indeed nice analysis. Agree with most of your selections.

Having attended all the games in Penticton I certailnly have to say that Hunter Shinkaruk was outstanding and made a huge impact with his play. As much as I like Poirier no question Shinkaruk wins this battle hands down.

In my view Ferland was the best Flames forward if not in the entire tournament. points and strong physical presence. Also a strong leader on and off the ice. Players gravitate towards him in the seats watching the other games. A strong leader and greatly recognized by his teammates.

I thought Ortio has made great strides in the past year. I had him rated at the bottom end of Flame goalie prospects but has obviously leaped forward as a result of Penticton.

Monahan is the real deal and smooth as silk. Nine Flames games, another year in Ottawa and playing world juniors will be all that his required for him to be a starting centre in 2014.

In the future I think Ramage and Seiloff will be tough highly skilled defenseman for years to come.

I would have liked to see the Flames vs Jets as I believe both franchises have the best young talent.

Thanks again for the grat analysis!

Avatar
#17 ChinookArch
September 11 2013, 07:25PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
5
props
Kent Wilson wrote:

13 trashes on one comment now? YOU CAN ALL GO TO HELL.

So, what's the protocol here? Add more trash or prop for the trashes?

Avatar
#21 TRAV
September 11 2013, 08:15PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
0
props

Here is the release re: camp schedule/roster...

http://flames.nhl.com/club/news.htm?id=682159&navid=DL|CGY|home

Avatar
#22 seve927
September 11 2013, 08:34PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
7
props
Kevin McCartney wrote:

In fairness to Oiler fans, they are quick to point out that three of their skilled forward prospects stayed in Russia during the tournament, and they had a couple injuries coming into the tournament to Moroz and Petryk (an invite). Yeah, they've graduated a lot of young talent, but in contrast to the Flames (and others), I don't we saw the best prospect team possible for the Oilers.

The Oiler roster decision I'm most confused by is bringing 8 left handed defencemen and 0 right handed ones. Tough way to evaluate your blue line, never mind win games.

The Flames were missing a lot of prospects too. Probably 5 of their top 15 in Gaudreau (2), Gillies, Klimchuk(top 10) and arguably Jankowski, Arnold and Agostino as well. And several others in DeBlouw, Gilmour, Rafikov, Harrison. I'd hardly say that this is the best prospect team they could ice.

Avatar
#23 44stampede
September 11 2013, 09:18PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
2
props

I wonder if the Petan and Shinkaruk picks will come back to haunt us. Guys with skill are just hard to come by vs 3rd line potential, big bodied players.

Time will tell I guess...

Avatar
#24 clyde
September 11 2013, 10:38PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
4
props
44stampede wrote:

I wonder if the Petan and Shinkaruk picks will come back to haunt us. Guys with skill are just hard to come by vs 3rd line potential, big bodied players.

Time will tell I guess...

I think the skill is being drafted. As we are seeing guys like Ferland and Knazig may be a reach but could end up being home runs. And, they aren't being drafted at the expense of drafting skilled guys but rather, as well as drafting skilled guys.

Avatar
#25 Franko J
September 11 2013, 10:49PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
4
props

Great article.

Good to see Monahan and Grandlund selected as 1 and 2 centres in the tournament.

For years and years this team clamoured for centres and although a very small size, the future at the pivot spot appears to be brighter than it has been in a very long time.

When was the last time this team has been mentioned at the center position without talking about who was going to compliment a certain RW?

I stand corrected and would like to apologize for my earlier remarks about Keegan Kanzig being no more than a "pylon" after he was drafted. With improved skating he will be scary to play against in the future. Just like Ferland, Kanzig has plenty of attributes it just a matter of time of figuring out what it will take to be a pro at the next level.

If there is one thing that is most notable with this tournament is the fact the Flames drafting is improving. The team is beginning to draft players who fans can be excited about.

Avatar
#26 Jeff Lebowski
September 11 2013, 10:59PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
4
props
beloch wrote:

To be fair to the Oilers, Yakupov (19), the Nuge (20) and Hall (21) are all young enough to have been in this tournament and probably would have topped everyone's lists. The flipside is that they really don't have many other kids left in their system to get excited about. Also, while they will be hard pressed to make the playoffs this year and may peak as a bubble team, the Oilers probably won't pick in the top 5 again for quite a while.

I'm a little worried about Vancouver personally. They have decidedly too many good prospects for a team that was recently a cup contender. If they choose to squander that in a bid to contend, I hope Burke and Feaster (Beaster?) are first in line to fleece them (so long as they don't try to pick up Shinkaruk)!

What I find encouraging for the Flames is that they made such a good showing with so many top prospects out of the picture! Gillies, Gaudreau, Klimchuk , and Jankowski (okay, I'm being optimistic about Janko.) were all unable to attend the tournament.

You nailed it. You very well should have great young talent with first overall picks. The life blood of a team is how fruitful later rounds are.

Calgary seems to have done this with so many mentions. Sven not at all distinguished but it means less with the relative abundance of good showings that impressed McCartney. Recall how good the college kids were in dev camp. I can see it in Jankowski too. Gaudreau in the mix?! Agostino and Arnold would have impressed in Penticton just like they did in Calgary. Jooris might be better than Knight. Calgary is deep with prospects. I mean scary deep. Huge kudos to Weisbrod and scouts. It could get even better with upcoming drafts.

I really believe they're on to something special.

With the comments on Poirier I think he didn't get the opportunity to really showcase his game because Calgary just rotated special team personnel. Poirier on PK would really show how valuable his skillset is.

My prediction is that Monahan, Poirier and Culkin with make the backbone of the future PK. It will be a weapon.

If Ferland and Kanzig are actual players you have two very tough kids to make Burke happy. Not to mention police the front and back end. Wishful I know, but you can kind of see that they have what it takes (perhaps not right now but...).

Ortio and it looks like Gillies too?! One word: assets. Valuable assets.

Why worry about any other team with Calgary's future prospects already looking good? Their fans should be worried about Calgary.

Avatar
#28 RexLibris
September 12 2013, 07:12AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
3
props
BurningSensation wrote:

I'm more jacked by the sheer volume of prospects we have bubbling under. Monahan gets 1st team, Granlund and Ramage 2nd, Ortio, Ferland, and Kanzig HMs.

And not an Oiler in sight (ok, ok, Marco Roy was an HM)

As a rebuilding team having that many guys flashing strong potential is a serious cause for optimism!

Monahan being our top pick in a deep draft is no surprise, and with Ramage being older he really isn't either. But Granlund, Ortio, Ferland and Kanzig were all something of a surprise for me at the tournament.

To steal from Andrew Sullivan, 'know hope'

Brandon Davidson made the 1st team All-Star list and was Captain of the Oilers rookie team.

Heck of a story on the young man, too.

Avatar
#29 coachedpotatoe
September 12 2013, 08:40AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
0
props
TRAV wrote:

Here is the release re: camp schedule/roster...

http://flames.nhl.com/club/news.htm?id=682159&navid=DL|CGY|home

Has anyone else looked at the rosters for the three teams? I'm trying to figure out who they have Sven playing with on the third team? He struggled so much in my mind at the tournie and now I'm not sure who he will be matched with. I look at the other teams as well and worry about building line chemistry when many of the possible lines make little sense to me.

Avatar
#30 Prairie Chicken by-the-Sea
September 12 2013, 08:45AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
1
props
Kent Wilson wrote:

13 trashes on one comment now? YOU CAN ALL GO TO HELL.

Cheer up Kent. If I had to cheer for the Jets, and the Bombers, AND live in Winnipeg I'd tend to be bitter and lash out as well.

That said, great analysis by Kevin. I especially appreciate the insightful comparison of Poirier and Shinkaruk. We will be watching that matchup for years.

Avatar
#31 aloudoun
September 12 2013, 10:55PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Props
1
props

Yes the Oilers top players were young enough to be in the tournament but you cant play if you have played for than 25 NHL games...

Comments are closed for this article.